Having a Voice Is Not the Same as Being Heard: The Real Challenge of Inclusion
Having a team made up of people of different ages, genders, cultural backgrounds and professional experiences is often seen as a sign of diversity. But does this mean that everyone has the same opportunity to participate, express opinions and influence decisions? And are all opinions valued equally, regardless of who expresses them?
These questions highlight a fundamental distinction: diversity concerns the presence of different people within an organisation, while inclusion means ensuring that everyone has genuine opportuni ties to participate and contribute to decision-making.
In a 2023 article published in the scientific journal Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, Elizabeth W. Morrison reviews a decade of research on employee voice and employee silence. The research shows that the decision to express ideas, suggestions or concerns does not depend solely on individual initiative or confidence. It is also influenced by hierarchical relationships, the working environment and the potential consequences of speaking up. An employee may identify an important problem and still choose to remain silent for fear of being ignored, criticised or perceived as troublesome.
However, feeling free to speak does not necessarily mean being heard. A study published in 2022 in the Academy of Management Journal, conducted by Elizabeth J. McClean, Sijun Kim and Tomas Martinez, shows that the recognition given to proposals can be influenced by the gender of the person presenting them and the way in which they are communicated. In other words, whether an idea is accepted does not always depend exclusively on its content.
Consider a team meeting: a suggestion made by a more experienced employee or someone close to management may be immediately valued, while a similar idea put forward by a newcomer or someone in a lower-ranking position may go unnoticed. The difference does not necessarily lie in the quality of the proposal, but in the credibility attributed to the person presenting it.
In micro and small enterprises, these dynamics deserve particular attention. Close relationships between employees and managers can facilitate communication, but they can also make power dynamics less visible. When decisions depend on a small group of people or on existing informal relationships, some opinions may carry more weight than others, regardless of their relevance.
It is therefore important to distinguish between giving people the opportunity to speak and ensuring that their contributions are genuinely considered. A company may encourage participation while consistently giving greater weight to the opinions of the same individuals. Similarly, the absence of criticism or conflict does not necessarily indicate an inclusive working environment: silence may reflect agreement, but it may also reflect the belief that speaking up or disagreeing is pointless.
This does not mean that all opinions should carry equal weight in every situation. Experience, technical expertise and professional responsibilities are legitimate criteria in decision-making. The problem arises when the recognition of contributions depends less on their quality than on the status, personal characteristics or proximity to decision-makers of those expressing them.
This inequality does not affect employees alone. When certain perspectives are systematically ignored, companies may lose valuable knowledge, ideas and information. A team may bring together people with very different experiences and still continue to make decisions based on a limited range of viewpoints.
Diversity alone, therefore, does not guarantee a greater plurality of perspectives. For that plurality to become a reality, it is necessary to question not only who is part of the team, but also who is heard, who is taken seriously and who has the opportunity to influence decisions.
Because genuine inclusion is not just about giving everyone a voice, but also about ensuring that the value of that voice is not determined by who they are or the position they hold.
References
Morrison, E. W. (2023). Employee Voice and Silence: Taking Stock a Decade Later. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 10, 79–107.
https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-orgpsych-120920-054654
McClean, E. J., Kim, S., & Martinez, T. (2022). Which Ideas for Change Are Endorsed? How Agentic and Communal Voice Affects Endorsement Differently for Men and for Women. Academy of Management Journal.